Guest Editorial

Poll petition ban would silence voice of Maine public

Barring the organizers of true citizen-led initiatives from our state's polling places won't stop well-funded outsiders from buying their way onto the ballot
By The Portland Press Herald Editorial Board | Jan 11, 2018

What, exactly, is wrong with Maine’s system of citizen-initiated referendums?

Worried about the sheer number of initiatives put before voters, the difficulty of dictating policy through the ballot box, and the system’s vulnerability to well financed outside influence, lawmakers have struggled with that question.

This session’s first attempt at an answer, through a proposal from Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap, gets them no closer to a solution.

Dunlap’s bill, L.D. 1726, includes a provision that would ban the gathering of signatures from within 50 feet of the entrance to a polling place, and would require a 50-foot activity-free pathway from parking areas or drop-off points to the entrance of polling places.

Dunlap says these signature-gatherers can be intimidating and disruptive, and that he is merely protecting voters and the municipal clerks who run polling places.

He is overstating the case, to say the least. As the secretary of state himself has pointed out, Maine elections are notable for how well they are run, and for how many voters participate. Petitioners generally are respectful and clear on where their boundaries lie.

The same cannot be said of the York County casino campaign, which culminated in a historic loss Nov. 7. Campaign organizers gathered signatures on the street using well paid workers, some of whom employed misleading tactics to convince voters to sign.

And that’s the problem with Dunlap’s proposal – whatever its purpose, banning petitioners from the polls would harm the ability of Maine residents to participate in direct democracy while doing nothing to keep well funded out-of-state campaigns from targeting our state. It would hinder the ability of Maine residents to respond when the Legislature doesn’t, say, raise the minimum wage, expand Medicaid or increase school funding – all things approved by voters after years of legislative gridlock – but it would do nothing to keep a casino developer with millions of dollars to spare from buying his way onto the ballot.

Gathering signatures at the polls is critical to the success of true citizen-led initiatives – there is no other time when so many registered voters are gathered in one place at the same time. Campaigns run largely with volunteer help can’t afford to seek voters out solely on the street.

But Shawn Scott can. Leading the casino campaign, he paid workers up to $17 a signature, a previously unheard-of rate.

In that and other ways, Scott’s campaign made a mockery of the citizen initiative. If lawmakers are looking for what’s wrong with the process, they should start there.

This Day in History: 1989

Reagan gives his farewell address

"After eight years as president of the United States, Ronald Reagan gives his farewell address to the American people. In his speech, President Reagan spoke with particular enthusiasm about the foreign policy achievements of his administration," says

"...Reagan declared that America 'rediscovered' its commitment to world freedom in the 1980s. The United States was 'respected again in the world and looked to for leadership.'"

"...Reagan proudly enumerated the successes of his vigorous foreign policy: achieving peace in the Persian Gulf, forcing the Soviets to begin departing from Afghanistan, and negotiating for the withdrawal of Vietnamese troops from Cambodia and Cuban forces from Angola. These efforts were all waged against communism, the ideology that Reagan believed was the main threat to freedom."

The reality was a bit more complicated and included massively increased defense spending and national debt. Peace in the Persian Gulf turned out to be temporary, and the Iran-Contra scandal revealed questionable methods of reaching anticommunist ends.

"Nonetheless, the achievements of his administration gained him much favor with the American public, and Ronald Reagan left office as one of the most popular modern U.S. presidents."


Comments (0)
If you wish to comment, please login.