Legislators, lobstermen press case against 'draconian' whale rules

Sep 21, 2019
Courtesy of: Rep. Jeffrey Evangelos From left, Rep. Bill Pluecker, Philip Bramhall, Carl Woodman, Jeff  Woodman, and Rep. Jeffrey Evangelos met Wednesday, Sept. 18, with the Maine attorney general and staff attorneys.

Augusta — Two area legislators led a delegation Wednesday, Sept. 18, to the state Attorney General's Office to press their case for a full representation for the state's lobster industry against what they say are draconian and unjustified measures being proposed by the federal government to protect right whales.

Independent Reps. Jeffrey Evangelos of Friendship and Bill Pluecker of Warren met with Attorney General Aaron Frey and two staff attorneys who represent the Department of Marine Resources. Joining the legislators in pressing the case were Philip Bramhall, co-owner of Bramhall's wharf in Friendship; Carl Woodman of Owls Head; and Jeff Woodman, who owns and operates Mainely Lobster out of Thomaston.

In  a joint statement released after the meeting, Evangelos and Pluecker stated that "the Attorney General and his staff listened to our concerns carefully. The staff explained that there is a two-track battle going on at the moment, one in federal court and one with the regulators."

According to the news release from the legislators, Bramhall impressed upon the state's attorneys the importance of the lobster industry to the coastal economy, stating that "it's not just the 4,500 lobstermen and women going out to haul each day, you have to add in another 5,000 plus sternmen, and all the families and children dependent on the industry. Then add in all the other people and businesses dependent of the success of the fishery, from banks, to bait dealers, boat builders, trap companies, car and truck dealerships, and everyone else, you're talking easily 50,000 to 100,000 people."

Jeff Woodman told the attorney general that "if the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration succeeds in promulgating unreasonable gear restrictions, there would be an economic depression from Kittery to Eastport, followed by numerous bankruptcies."

Carl Woodman agreed, stating that "We all care about the right whale, we've been practicing conservation for 20 years. But where's the evidence that Maine's lobster industry has ever harmed a right whale, there is none. The vast majority of whale deaths are in Canada, why should we be taking the hit for them?"

The attorney general and his staff told the group that they are on the case and are working carefully with Marine Resources Commissioner Pat Keliher, who is negotiating with NOAA as it develops its proposal, according to the news release.

Evangelos and Pluecker stated that they "wanted the Attorney General's Office to promise they would go to court and intervene on behalf of the lobster industry."

In response to this request, the staff attorney who also represents DMR stated that, "in the event NOAA proposes draconian or unreasonable measures, "I want you to know we've got your back and we plan on doing everything we can to assure that any proposed regulations are reasonable and if they aren't, all legal options are on the table."

After the meeting, the lobstermen and the two legislators met. The lobstermen issued a statement, saying, "We're very satisfied with the results of the meeting. We came up here to secure legal representation for our industry, and we left confident that this is in fact the case."

Comments (1)
Posted by: Mary A McKeever | Sep 21, 2019 13:10

I support the view of the lobstermen. Hopefully they will get the leniency they deserve. It is a hard life they lead and the public, me for one, love to eat lobster. Please give the Lobstermen a break!



If you wish to comment, please login.