Walmart appeals to state for massive tax breaks for Thomaston store

By Stephen Betts | Oct 31, 2019

Thomaston — Walmart has appealed to the state to get property tax breaks for the past two years totaling nearly $340,000 from Thomaston.

The Thomaston Board of Assessors voted in the spring to reject the request of the international retail giant to cut its property valuation by nearly half. Walmart then appealed to the state.

Thomaston Assessor's Agent David Martucci said Oct. 31 that a hearing has yet to be scheduled by the Maine Board of Property Tax Review. The town and Walmart participated in state-required mediation but Martucci said no agreement was reached.

Any decision of the state Board can be appealed to state court.

Walmart is the town's second-highest property taxpayer.

The Thomaston Walmart store opened in October 2013, relocating from Rockland.

The 2019-2020 assessment on Walmart's store and land in Thomaston totals $15.5 million with a tax bill of $392,000.

Cement manufacturer Dragon Products is the top taxpayer in town with a bill for 2018-2019 of $1,646,080.

Walmart is seeking to have its assessment for 2018-2019 reduced from $15,464,000 to $7.4 million. This would cut its tax bill by $168,780. A similar request for its 2018-2019 assessment has also been sought by Walmart.

The Maine Center for Economic Policy issued a report on Thursday, Oct. 31 on how big-box stores are trying to get tax breaks in the state. The report stated that large retailers are" ramping up their challenges of local assessments in an effort to secure tax cuts"

The report lists Walmart, Lowe’s, Walgreens, Sam’s Club, Best Buy, and BJ’s, stating they have requested $184 million in valuation reductions since 2015.

"Across the country, the large retailers that own big-box stores have used this dubious legal theory to challenge local assessments, arguing they should be taxed as if their properties were shuttered and vacant 'dark stores' — even while they’re open for business and raking in revenue," said Sarah Austin, MECEP policy analyst and the report's author. "It’s an effort by major corporations to manipulate the tax code so they pay less, leaving towns and other property taxpayers holding the bill."

The Board of Assessors signed a settlement agreement in April 2017 with Lowe's Home Centers LLC that ended that retailer's abatement requests, but also lowered the company's tax assessment for its Thomaston property from $15.6 million to $14,352,000 for three years.

Comments (9)
Posted by: Dale Hayward | Nov 01, 2019 22:16

Whether a person pays taxes is up to them, as they see fit, and for whatever reason be it right or wrong. If you both think I am stupid enough, having been a State Auditor to not know the difference that does not make you look very good in some eyes. Get it. Now if you think that those internet sales sellers collect and turn the tax over, you might be one bubble off plumb there also. Trying to point to me for whether or not I file is shameful on your part and you should both get fifty lashes for such a thought. I could easily go further on this but you both should know that not everyone doesnot do everything legal and proper and above board and in the best interest of all of us. Take the Rocklandia City Council for an example. Our taxes could be lower if they had a conscious and served the people as they did in the old days, fair and square.

Posted by: Gerald A Weinand | Nov 01, 2019 17:59

Internet sales (or sales from "remote sellers) have been taxed in Maine since July 2018:

Posted by: Robin Gabe | Nov 01, 2019 15:56

Of course, Dale, you have to figure those untaxed internet sales  as use tax on your Maine income tax (unless you don't  file).

Posted by: Dale Hayward | Nov 01, 2019 15:06

Only one way to deal with Wallymart. DO NOT SHOP THERE. No choice you say, go online and avoid sales taxes for many sales and  maybe better prices.

Posted by: Lucinda Lang | Nov 01, 2019 11:03

Hopefully now Economic Development committees, Planning Boards, Code Officers & Comprehensive plans may learn from this.  Walmart and many "big box" are well know for property tax rebates and reductions.  This is one of the reasons so many towns in Maine and across the country said NO to Walmart and Home Depot and Lowes and other big box stores.


Posted by: Ronald Horvath | Nov 01, 2019 06:33

Seriously?  The Waltons aren't big enough billionaires that they have to cheat a small town?


"Walmart makes $14.7 billion a year in profit and $482 billion a year in total revenue. That would make Walmart the 12th biggest country in the world, if it were a country. Walmart makes $40 million a day in profit and $466 in profit every second."

Posted by: ALBERT E COLSON | Oct 31, 2019 21:44

You are so right Richard .

Posted by: Ananur Forma | Oct 31, 2019 19:37

How dare they!

Posted by: Richard McKusic, Sr. | Oct 31, 2019 16:30

Why not?  Rockland's Main Street has their tax breaks at the homeowners' expense.


If you wish to comment, please login.