An insurance company for an Owls Head man, accused of physically assaulting and terrorizing a former partner, filed a complaint in Knox County Superior Court Sept.16, asking not be solely responsible for compensating the defendant should the victim be awarded damages.

A Camden woman filed a civil complaint against Randy B. Smith, her ex-partner who lied to her about being a friend of her late husband, physically assaulted her, and restrained her to a bed when she tried to leave him.

Smith has a warrant out for his arrest for violating a protection from abuse order, but has not yet been captured. A motion to revoke Smith's bail was also filed. Darby C. Urey, the victim's attorney, said Smith is most likely out-of-state.

Judge Patricia Worth granted an attachment April 24 of $100,000 on the property of the defendant, ruling the plaintiff is likely to recover money from him on counts of assault, battery, false imprisonment and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Smith's insurance company, MMG Insurance Company, has filed the complaint against Amica Mutual Insurance Company, Smith, and the victim who filed the initial complaint against Smith.

Urey said the case has been set back about three months so the second insurance company can be added to the case.

The company contends that Amica has a duty to defend Smith and allocate defense costs with MMG. Amica refused to defend Smith in the civil case, and also refuses to be liable if damages are won, the complaint states.

If the court concludes Amica does not have a duty to compensate Smith in the civil case, then MMG also requests the court declare they do not have a duty to do so, either.

The insurance company, MMG, issued a homeowners insurance policy that was in effect until January 2015. The policy had been in effect for four months prior to the filing of the action, said court papers. MMG contends that Amica issued Smith various policies that were in effect the entire 32-month period the victim alleges the abuse occurred.

In the initial civil case, Smith rebuts the allegations and will testify they are false, according to court papers filed by his attorney Harold B. Stewart of Presque Isle. Smith also alleges the victim was the aggressor.

The victim now has a protection from abuse order on Smith, but he continues to contact her through text messages. The district attorney has pending domestic violence assault and obstructing the report of a crime charges against him, said the complaint.

The victim's husband died in 2009 in an accident. Six months later, the defendant approached her at an art gallery and told her he had been a friend of her husband.

A long-term relationship then began between the victim and Smith.

Later on in the relationship, Smith told the victim he lied, and he never knew her late husband.

He began to visit the victim for long periods of time, staying while uninvited, and refusing to leave, said the complaint.

Smith admits he lied to the victim about knowing her husband, according to court documents.

When Smith convinced the victim to allow him to live with her in her Rockland home, he began to physically and mentally abuse the victim, said the complaint. When he was asked to leave, he would pretend to honor her request, but would later come back to the house and would be found hiding in the basement.

The victim said she did not call police about the abuse initially because she was embarrassed, said court papers.

Smith also took the victim's engagement ring from her late husband, demanding she wear a ring he gave her, said the complaint, and when she attempted to end the relationship, he threatened to stab her and whoever she dated.

Smith assaulted the victim several times, including punching her in the face with a closed fist and restraining her to the bed in a contorted fashion. As she struggled to escape, she suffered a back injury, said the complaint.

When she attempted to call police, Smith ripped the telephone wires out of the wall, said the complaint.

He also told the victim he stole Ambien with the intent to drug her while they were on vacation.

From the prolonged abuse at the hands of Smith, the victim has suffered severe emotional and physical injury, and has payed significant sums of money for medical treatment, said the complaint.

Courier Publications' reporter Juliette Laaka can be reached at 594-4401 ext. 118 or via email at