Dragon receives state approval for mercury emission increase

Natural Resources Council of Maine voices concern
By Kim Lincoln | Jul 17, 2014

Thomaston — Dragon Products received approval July 17 from the Board of Environmental Protection to increase its mercury emissions limit.

Dragon, which operates the cement plant in Thomaston, applied to use the federal limit of 42 pounds per year rather than the state limit of 25 pounds per year.

"We are pleased with the board's decision that alignment of Dragon's mercury emission limit with the EPA's production-based limit meets the standard established by the Maine Legislature for alternative mercury emissions limits," stated Plant Manager Ray DeGrass in a press release July 18.

The Natural Resources Council of Maine is disappointed in the board's vote, which they expressed in a statement from its Clean Energy Project Director, Dylan Voorhees.

In February, Degrass and Environmental Manager Michael Martunas said that if the plant had to go by the state standard, it would "curtail production dramatically." Degrass said that would keep the plant operating at recession levels.

He argued the state's limit on emissions would not prevent a cement company from out of state selling to customers in Maine, filling a demand Dragon would not be able to due to the limits.

In 2008, the Maine Legislature reduced the mercury emission limit from 35 pounds per year to 25 pounds per year, but allowed plants to apply for an alternative limit. Companies had to submit a mercury reduction plan to the Department of Environmental Protection and perform emissions testing.

By 2013, companies were required to develop a second mercury reduction plan, incorporating the results of the four mercury emission tests, and submit the updated plan to DEP.

"In recommending support for this request from the Spanish-owned Dragon Cement Company, DEP is effectively surrendering the state’s ability to limit mercury emissions at Dragon, allowing the plant to pollute at the highest level permitted nationwide," Voorhees said in a statement.

Dragon Cement Company’s request flies in the face of Maine’s law to limit mercury, and the state’s Mercury Action Plan too. Maine joined with the Conference of New England Governors and Eastern Canadian Premiers in adopting the action plan, the goal of which is the virtual elimination of anthropogenic mercury emissions, according to a news release from NRCM.

"Dragon met all of the testing and reporting requirements. On March 3, 2013, DEP submitted a Mercury Reduction Report to the ENR Committee. The Department's Report discussed Dragon's research and mercury emissions studies in detail, and ultimately recommended Dragon's limit align with the newly promulgated federal emission limit for mercury," according to information in a memo sent earlier this year to Rockland City Council.

"It [Dragon] put at least 13 pounds of toxic mercury per year into Maine’s environment in 2011-2012. That may not sound like much, but, over time, just one gram of mercury in the air deposited in a 20-acre lake each year, can contaminate the fish in that lake and 13 pounds is almost 6,000 grams," Voorhees said in the news release.

Voorhees said there is no reason that Maine should not require Dragon to install widely available control technologies such as activated carbon injection or wet scrubbers. To do so would be the equivalent of eliminating Maine’s third largest single source of mercury pollution.

"...EPA's new rule also requires the installation of a Continuous Emissions Monitoring System (CEMS) for mercury emissions. Under the new federal emission standards, Dragon's mercury emission limit, at maximum theoretical production, is 42 pounds per year," information from Dragon stated.

Courier Publications Copy Editor Kim Lincoln can be reached at 594-4401 or by email at klincoln@villagesoup.com.

Comments (7)
Posted by: Judy Olson | Jul 30, 2014 10:16

The DEP/EPA is useless.  Corporate greed trumps environmental and health concerns.  I agree that the lobstermen and anyone engaging in the fishing industry should conduct testing on the effects of the emissions especially considering the importance of the fishing industry to this county and concerns for our health when eating products that are exposed to dioxins, mercury & lead contamination generated from the stacks of Dragon Cement.



Posted by: Heidi L Washburn | Jul 21, 2014 17:56

Clean air, clean water and healthy food sources should ALWAYS, ALWAYS trump the $$$ bottom line.

 



Posted by: Lorelie Davis | Jul 20, 2014 09:10

So, as usual, rules can be waived all in the name of money.  Sickening.  No wonder we have such a high cancer rate.



Posted by: Kathryn Fogg | Jul 19, 2014 09:19

That increase is not a small amount, it is nearly double from what is allowed.  Would Dragon please  explain to us lay people how they handle these emissions and how they are released?

 



Posted by: Susan Sinclair | Jul 18, 2014 22:36

So the next time people are all kinds of down about the federal government putting too strict.regulations on businesses, they can remember Dragon with a warm heart. Awwwww....



Posted by: James York | Jul 18, 2014 09:52

"Dragon Plant Manager Ray Degrass and Environmental Manager Michael Martunas said that if the plant had to go by the state standard, it would "curtail production dramatically." Degrass said that would keep the plant operating at recession levels."   It seems to me that the fisherman of our communities at least need a study to see how the increases in mercury could effect the fisheries of PenBay before Dragon be given the ok increase their emissions.  Looks like the Board of Environmental Protection is more interested in Dragon's profits than the people of the midcoast, many who rely on a healthy environment to make a living.

 



Posted by: Maggie Trout | Jul 17, 2014 21:13

So, the bottom line of the Board's Findings of Fact is that it would cost Dragon too much money to maintain Maine standards.  There is not one word of reference to health effects.  Both Rockland and Thomaston benefit financially from taxes paid by Dragon, but at what cost.



If you wish to comment, please login.

Staff Profile

Kim Lincoln
Editor
594-4401 ext. 120
Email Me

The Camden Herald editor Kim Lincoln has worked for Courier Publications since 2003.

During her time with the company she has worked for each of the three newspapers, The Courier-Gazette, The Camden Herald and The Republican Journal.

When she is not in the newsroom, Kim likes to be outside, whether it be gardening, swimming, hiking or just enjoying the sunshine.

Recent Stories by Kim Lincoln